Should Ubuntu put recovery partitions into GRUB?

Asked by Andrew Riker

I recently purchased an ASUS notebook (M50VM-B1), and I put Kubuntu 8.10 on it. It recognized my Windows Vista installation automatically, and it also recognized my recovery partition. It put both into GRUB as "Windows Vista (loader)".

 When I restarted my computer I was confronted with 2 "Windows Vista (loader)"s. I didn't know which to chose, so I picked the first one. It was the recovery partition. Unfortunately, when I booted to the recovery partition, a process corrupted GRUB, so when I rebooted, I only got a GRUB error, and I couldn't boot to any OS.

I figured out what had happened, reinstalled Kubuntu, and removed the first "Windows Vista (loader)" from GRUB. Thereafter, I didn't have any problems. However, I think that if someone who has less technical knowledge was faced with the same situation, they would probably panic and bring the computer to the repair shop. This would likely prevent that user from trying Linux again and possibly damage Linux's reputation.

I don't know that every manufacturer's recovery partition would do this, but it brings up an interesting question. Should Ubuntu put bootable recovery partitions into GRUB or let Windows manage it? If only Windows should manage it, is there an easy way for Ubuntu to differentiate between a Windows partition and the recovery partition, and only put the former into GRUB? If not, is it possible to label one "Windows Vista (loader)" and the other "Vista Recovery"?

Question information

Language:
English Edit question
Status:
Answered
For:
Ubuntu grub Edit question
Assignee:
No assignee Edit question
Last query:
Last reply:
Revision history for this message
nhasian (nhasian) said :
#1

Hello andrew,

i havent used an asus notebook, but on Hp and Dell notebooks, if you were to accidentally launch the recovery partition it would tell you it was going to do a system restore and ask if you would like to continue. If the asus one just starts 'repairing' stuff immediately on launch that can be troublesome. Good job editing the grub menu to remove the rescue partition though.

Can you help with this problem?

Provide an answer of your own, or ask Andrew Riker for more information if necessary.

To post a message you must log in.