Exchange 2003 with evolution

Asked by MichaelB

Hi,

I would like to replace Windows XP with Ubuntu 10.04 in a company and i have to test all functionality that i need. This project started 1 year ago but i still have big problems with Exchange 2003. This company use Exchange from 5 years (email, shared calendar, contact) and it will not change it sooner.

Evolution version shipped with 10.04 still buggy for Exchange (i tested), so i tried the PPA "evo230" with mapi. It work a lot better but i cannot write event in the calendar.. so it still unusable for a company that use Exchange!

Which evolution package work for that (email, calendar, contact) ?
It is possible or not ?

Is stupid because it is the only blocker and if i cannot do that, we must migrate to Windows 7/Office...

Thanks for your help,
Michael

Question information

Language:
English Edit question
Status:
Answered
For:
Ubuntu evolution Edit question
Assignee:
No assignee Edit question
Last query:
Last reply:
Revision history for this message
actionparsnip (andrew-woodhead666) said :
#1

You may be able to run MSOffice in wine. Evolution hates non-MS clients so if the workplace productivity is ingrained with Exchange then you may be stuck. Ubuntu isn't always the answer.

http://appdb.winehq.org/objectManager.php?sClass=application&iId=31

Revision history for this message
MichaelB (mrbou) said :
#2

Yes i tried to run Outlook 2003 with Wine 1.2 (ubuntu-wine PPA) in lucid, install was ok, Outlook 2003 running but impossible to configure a Exchange account (he cannot find exchange mailbox ?).. and i'm sure with the parameters because the procedure work in xp..

So i still blocked... i personally and professionally use linux from 11 years, Ubuntu from 3 years and there is a really great progress in a short period, but it still missing some essentials things (in this case with exchange). I know that my problem is not a Ubuntu defect but a "Evolution" (gnome or novell) problem, and i don't really understand why they don't put a higher priority on that thing (evolution-exchange, evolution-mapi) because with my experience i saw that this is the biggest problem and blocker in a company that want migrate to linux (if they use exchange)..

I hope that evolution 2.32, will fix some missing things with exchange..

Thanks,
Michael

Revision history for this message
actionparsnip (andrew-woodhead666) said :
#3

Maybe Exchange should accept Evolution clients ;)

You could pressure Microsoft to support 3rd party clients.

Revision history for this message
MichaelB (mrbou) said :
#4

So i found a good solution to connect evolution / thunderbird client to Microsoft Exchange 2003.

I tried DavMail (davmail.sourceforge.net) and install it on my Ubuntu test computer (you can install locally or install it on a server).
All that i needed seems to work (email, calendar, contact). i have to test it in the next days..

First i wanted to use Evolution with DavMail but it fail when retrieving email because the Exchange mail box was big (~15000 mail, ~2Go) and Evolution crashed with a timeout.. :o( (it work with a lighter mail box)

So i decide to switch to Thunderbird with lightning extension for the calendar.. and is ok until now :o)

Revision history for this message
Kyle Guilbert (kguilbert) said :
#5

I've been using (tolerating) Evolution for years to access an Exchange server, and although it's mostly feature-complete, it's always been incredibly buggy. I have an icon in my Panel to run 'evolution --force-shutdown'. Here are the problems I've always had:

- Often loses the connection to the exchange backend process.
- It has some sort of task infrastructure that is flaky.. it shows you its current tasks in the status bar, each with a red 'X' to cancel them. Doing this is perilous, and often results in you having to restart evolution to get things working again.
- The "Refreshing folder" and "Checking for new mail" tasks take a very long time. And I'm even careful to not keep my inbox too large. I'm not discounting the possibility of this being partly a server-side problem, but using our Exchange Web interface is really snappy.
- Creating appointments (and inviting people to them) almost never works, to the point where I don't even try it anymore. I use the server's web interface for that now, which is many clicks away.
- Using the address auto-complete feature with addresses in the Global Address List often freezes Evolution for ~30 seconds, sometimes indefinitely. Sometimes it renders the mouse cursor unusable in X entirely, requiring me to kill Evolution to get it back.

Can you help with this problem?

Provide an answer of your own, or ask MichaelB for more information if necessary.

To post a message you must log in.