Error: Failed despite same graph (STOP 4) in SMEFTsim for operator involving gluon fields
Dear MadGraph authors,
I am trying to generate interference and pure quadratic samples for the operator cHG defined in SMEFTsim topU3l UFO model [1] and process:
import model SMEFTsim_
define p = g u d d~ b b~
define j = g u d d~ b b~
generate p p > e+ ve j j j j SMHLOOP=0 QCD=2 NP=1
output emVjj_cHG_SM_LI_QU
Although we are aware of the problems related to these kind of operators involving gluon fields but without dependence on as [3], it is still not clear the source of the following error:
Added good helicity 208 89.392844928797473 in event 1 local: 1
RESET CUMULATIVE VARIABLE
RESET CUMULATIVE VARIABLE
Error: Failed despite same graph: 1296
Have jets (>0) 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1
Should be 6 7 8
STOP 4
This happens for MG5 version 2.6.5, 2.7.3 and LS 2.9.11.
The puzzling fact is that the MG reweighting at LO works, starting from the SM and reweighting to cHG=+1, cHG=-1 [4].
We tried the following combination for initial and final state partons but we can't find a clear connection with the success or fail for the execution of MG5:
define p = g; define j = g u u~ d -> OK
define p = g u; define j = g u u~ d -> OK
define p = g u d; define j = g u u~ d -> OK
define p = g u u~; define j = g u u~ d -> OK
define p = g u u~ d; define j = g u u~ d -> OK
define p = g u d u~ d~; define j = g u u~ d -> ERROR
Could you tell us what is happening behind the curtains? Should we "thrust" the result from the LO reweighting?
Thank you,
Best
-------
[1]
https:/
[2]
https:/
https:/
[3]
Starting point:
import model SMEFTsim_
define p = g u u~ d d~ s s~ c c~ b b~
define j = p
generate p p > e- ve~ j j j j SMHLOOP=0 QCD=2
We change process and model at reweighting:
INFO: change model SMEFTsim_
KEEP: change process p p > e- ve~ j j j j NP=1 QCD=2 SMHLOOP=0
INFO: Event nb 0 current time: 03h12
INFO: Event nb 10 0.16s
INFO: Event nb 20 0.28s
INFO: Event nb 30 0.37s
INFO: Event nb 40 0.41s
INFO: Event nb 50 0.45s
INFO: Event nb 60 0.52s
INFO: Event nb 70 0.56s
INFO: Event nb 80 0.62s
INFO: Event nb 90 0.68s
INFO: Event nb 100 0.74s
INFO: Event nb 200 1.3s
INFO: Event nb 300 1.8s
INFO: Event nb 400 2.3s
INFO: Event nb 500 2.8s
INFO: Event nb 600 3.3s
INFO: Event nb 700 3.7s
INFO: Event nb 800 4.1s
INFO: Event nb 900 4.4s
INFO: All event done (nb_event: 1000) 4.7s
INFO: Event /srv/emVjj_
INFO: new cross-section is : 31.7643 pb (indicative error: 0.518991 pb)
INFO: Original cross-section: 32.14466 +- 0.03739602 pb (cross-section from sum of weights: 32.144645)
INFO: Computed cross-section:
INFO: cHG : 31.7642987594 +- 0.51899110219 pb
Question information
- Language:
- English Edit question
- Status:
- Solved
- Assignee:
- No assignee Edit question
- Solved by:
- Olivier Mattelaer
- Solved:
- Last query:
- Last reply: