Comment 8 for bug 237297

Revision history for this message
John A Meinel (jameinel) wrote :

putty is unable to get access to the terminal, so while it would prompt, the user would be unable to actually type their password/etc.

So we decided that just failing was better than hanging waiting on user input that it could never get (hence -batch).

I don't know about secure terminal access. I can say that openssh has done just fine-by-me for quite some time, at prompting for my password under cygwin. (I haven't tested much in plain cmd.exe)

I always just figured it was a simple limitation of putty.

I've personally switched away and am now using Pageant + Paramiko for almost all my connections, and I think Mark Hammond was probably right about it being the most sane default. plink.exe just isn't very good as a subprocess...